All about ED
Elbow dysplasia (ED) is a general term used to identify inherited polygenic diseases of the elbow in dogs. Affected animals may exhibit intermittent lameness or an abnormal gait which is aggravated by exercise or when the dog first moves following prolonged rest. Watch out for sudden or gradual front leg lameness, morning stiffness or stiffness after a period of rest. In this technical article, vet Peter van Dongen goes through the anatomy of ED.
Elbow Dysplasia (ED) is an abnormal development of the elbow joint and includes several primary specific abnormalities affecting different sites in the joint. These abnormalities involve the cartilage, which makes up the surface of the joint itself, or the other structures of the joint, such as the bones themselves, the synovial membrane and the ligaments and tendons surrounding the joint. The primary abnormalities cause secondary changes such as osteo-arthritis (arthrosis, degenerative joint disease (DJD)) due to excessive wear and tear of the joint. Most primary lesions occur in the young growing animal and are often present in both left and right elbow joint.The Elbow Joint
The elbow joint works like a hinge and allows movement mainly in one plane only. It is made up of three bones, which normally fit together perfectly (See photo and line drawings).
The single bone of the upper foreleg is called the humerus, the two bones of the lower foreleg are called the radius and the ulna. The ulna is the longer one, which makes up the point of the elbow, called the olecranon. The distal (furthest away from the body) part of the humerus is called the condyle, which has a medial (towards to inside of the body) and lateral (towards the outside) part. The proximal (closest to the body) part of the ulna has a medial and lateral coronoid process and an anconeal process, in between which the trochlear notch articulates with the humerus. The proximal part of the radius is called the radial head. The ends of the bones are all covered by hyaline cartilage (joint cartilage) which is normally very smooth. The joint is surrounded by a synovial sac, called the joint capsule, which contains the synovial fluid (joint fluid) to help lubricate the joint. The bones are held together by means of ligaments (collateral ligaments), one on either side of the joint. In addition several tendons cross the joint on either side.
If there is any change to the anatomical build of any part of the above, the joint will not fit together properly, leading to damage to one or more of the structures involved and an excessive wear and tear of the joint. The elbow joint is particularly prone to these changes as it is the major point of movement of the foreleg. The other joints of the foreleg, shoulder and carpus (wrist) do not move as much during the normal locomotion of the dog.
Causes of Elbow Dysplasia
The breeds which are prone to any particular primary condition are mentioned below. Males are affected more often than females, possibly due to their faster rate of growth or heavier build. One of the problems in deciding which dogs to breed from is the fact that many dogs which are affected genetically, or even anatomically, are not necessarily affected clinically. They may not show any clinical symptoms such as lameness. These dogs are called sub-clinical dogs. They can only be detected radiographically at the moment. In the future perhaps there will be DNA tests available to assess the genetic make up of a dog for a particular trait.
Endochondral ossification is one of the two processes in which bones are formed. In this case bone develops on a preformed cartilagenous matrix, either at the end of the bone or in the physis. It is the main process behind the growth in length of the long bones in the body.
Intra-membranous ossification is the second process in which bones are formed. In this case bone forms in bands of connective tissue. This happens in flat bones, such as the skull bones and the pelvis, and it is also the way in which bones grow in width. The primary conditions 1-6 are all thought to be due to osteochondrosis.
Dogs examined under the scheme are radiographed as described above, at an age of at least one year old, and the radiographs are then sent for examination by a select group of scrutinisers who have extensive experience in the assessment of radiographs. A grade for each elbow of each patient is decided upon, based on the presence or absence of primary lesions, as well as the presence or absence of any secondary changes in the joint. The score for each elbow can be: 0 if the joint is normal, 1 when there is mild ED, 2 if there is moderate ED or any primary lesion, and 3 if there is severe ED. The overall grade for each individual patient is the highest of the two scores, not the total, as in the hip scoring system. Only dogs with scores of 0 or 1 should be used for breeding purposes. The results of any dog radiographed under the ED scheme are kept on record by the Kennel Club. The effect of this system will only really be seen after several generations of selective breeding in the affected breeds.
Breeds most prone to ED
FCP: Labrador Retriever, the Golden Retriever, the Rottweiler, the German Shepherd Dog and The Bernese Mountain Dog. Other breeds affected are the St. Bernards, Chows, Rhodesian Ridgebacks and Newfoundlands. Symptoms usually develop between 4-5 months of age. Sometimes FCP and OCD occur in the same joint at the same time.
USP: German Shepherd Dog and the Bassett Hound. More rarely we see it in Wolfhounds, Rottweilers, St. Bernards and Great Danes. Symptoms usually develop between 4-5 months of age.
Un-united Medial Humeral Epicondyle: Labrador Retrievers are prone to this condition.
Short Ulna Syndrome: Great Danes, Irish Wolfhounds and the Bassett Hound or after trauma.
Congenital Dislocation of the Elbow - (lateral (outwards) rotation of the ulna. This is mostly seen in Shelties, Pekingese, Cocker Spaniels, Yorkshire Terriers, Boston Terriers, Miniature Poodles, Pugs, Chihuahuas and Miniature Pinschers. It is usually recognised within the first three months of life.
Congenital Dislocation of the Elbow (caudo-lateral (backwards and outwards) luxation of the radial head. This is mostly seen in Pekingese, Yorkshire Terriers, Pomeranians, Staffordshire Terriers, Boxers, Bulldogs, Bull Mastiffs, Old English Sheepdogs and Rough Collies. Affected animals are often 4-5 months old at presentation.
In May 1995 Peter started agility (after years of just thinking about it!) with his Jack Russell Cross 'Basil' (a bitch!), then 5 years old. Since then they have qualified for many finals, including 'Crufts' and 'Olympia'. Basil won the coveted Crufts 2001 title in the individual mini agility.
Peter passed the British Agility Club Instructors' exam in October 1999 and has since done the British Agility Club Judging Workshop.
Peter regularly writes for various agility magazines and web sites and has been the official British Team Vet for the Agility World Championships for the last three years.
Peter and his wife Carry still live in Borough Green with their two dogs and two cats. His little Jack Russell X, Sky, has just started agility training and will hopefully follow in Basil’s footsteps!
The term elbow dysplasia (ED) is a general term that is used to describe a developmental degenerative disease of the elbow joint. Understanding the symptoms and causes of ED is extremely important if informed decisions are to be made regarding diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of ED. The Working K-9 Vet Dr. Henry de Boer discusses this crippling disease, its causes and symptoms and diagnosis along with its treatment and prevention.
Q. I have been hearing a lot about elbow dysplasia recently. What exactly is elbow dysplasia? Are there symptoms I should be watching for in my young dog?
A. There are in fact three different etiologies that can create a diagnosis of ED. These etiologies may occur individually or in combination with each other in any one dog. This disease has created considerable confusion and controversy not only on the part of dog owner, but with practicing veterinarians as well as researchers who are studying the problem. While our ability to diagnose ED has improved in recent years, there is still a great deal to be learned about its causes, prevention, and what constitutes appropriate treatment.
ED occurs predominantly in medium or larger breeds of dogs. The Orthopedic Foundation for Animals (OFA) maintains statistics in their elbow registry for many breeds. As of December 31, 1998, ED had been diagnosed by OFA in 87 breeds. Incidences range from 0% in Border Collies up to 47.8% in Chow Chows. The average incidence of the breeds for which at least 75 individuals have been evaluated is 11.11%. Male dogs are more likely to have ED then females, and 20-35% of dogs with ED have it in both elbows.
Dogs with ED may or may not be lame, therefore, using lameness to determine its presence or the breed worthiness of an animal is foolhardy. Dogs with clinical ED typically develop foreleg lameness between the ages of 5-12 months of age, however, in some cases the lameness may not be apparent until as late as 5-7 years of age. The lameness may be variable and periodic. Some dogs may demonstrate soreness after rest, improve slightly with activity, but then worsen with increased activity. There may be intervals with no lameness at all. Jumping and sharp fast turns usually exaggerate the lameness. Pain can be elicited by overextending the elbow, and there may be a slight to moderate swelling noticeable when carefully feeling the elbow joint. If both legs are meaningfully affected the lameness may be more difficult to detect. Careful observation would show slight rotation of the top of the paws outwardly, as well as a stiff or stilted movement of the forelegs. There may be a reluctance on the dogs part to land hard on the front legs (e.g. trotting, loping or landing jumps).
For the sake of simplicity the three etiologies resulting in ED will be discussed individually, but it is important to note that there can be considerable overlapping in their presence, their cause and effect. The magnitude of the overlapping has probably not been fully realised at this time.
The anconeal process is a small pyramid shaped piece of bone on the upper end of the ulna. In a young dog, it is a piece of cartilage that gradually turns to bone and unites with the rest of the ulna at approximately 4 ½ - 5 months of age. If that union fails to take place we have an ununited anconeal process (UAP). The presence of UAP leads to degenerative joint disease as a result of a decrease in stability within the joint, and an increase in inflammation caused by the chip of bone being free within the joint.
Osteochondritis dessicans (OCD) can occur in many joints, but when it occurs in an elbow it most commonly is on the lower, inner aspect of the humurus (medial humural condyle). In essence OCD is a vertical fracture in the articular cartilage of the humurus, which can lead to a flap of cartilage within the joint. This flap leads to degeneration within the joint as a result of an inflammatory process.
The coronoid process is a small piece of bone on the ulna, which articulates with the humurus. Similar to the anconeal process it starts as cartilage, and gradually turns to bone as it unites with the rest of the ulna. Failure of that fusion to occur or chipping of the area after fusion has occurred, creates a fragmented coronoid process (FCP). Subsequent to FCP degenerative joint disease develops for the same reason as with UAP.
Causes The exact causes of ED have been the subject of considerable controversy. A number of predisposing factors have been identified, and recently some new theories have gained support as probable explanations for the development of ED. The individual etiologies of ED most likely have multiple possible causes.
OCD has at least three possible causes.
Understanding of the causes of FCD and UAP has experienced a surge in recent years. In addition to the causes listed for OCD, recent research strongly suggest that two factors are playing a major role in the development of these two etiologies. A disparity in the growth rate between the radius and ulna, as well as an abnormal formation of the trochleor notch in the ulna, have been implicated in the development of ED. The elbow joint is a very complex joint that is created by the junction of three different bones. Normally these bones fit and function together with very close tolerances. If the growth rate of the bones is changed, or a structure does not form normally, the tolerances change, enhancing the possibility of damage within the joint. The damage created typically results in either FCP or UAP.
In general elbow dysplasia should be suspected as a possiblity with any foreleg lameness that persists for more than several days, especially if the dog is of a breed that may be prone to ED. Examination of the leg yields pain on palpation when the elbow joint is over-extended. The next step in establishing a diagnosis is having high quality radiographs taken. Multiple views of the leg should be taken, and if ED is evident, radiographs of the other elbow are appropriate given the possibility of this problem occurring in both elbows. UAP is easily detected with radiographs, and in most cases, a diagnosis of OCD can be made with radiographs as well. FCP can be diagnosed in most cases with radiographs, but can be a challenge in yet other cases. The problem is that the coronoid process is a relatively small piece of bone that in the majority of standard radiographic views cannot be visualized by itself, but rather is superimposed on the other bony structures within the elbow. Given that superimpositon, if the lesion is small, it may be difficult if not impossible to see. In many of the cases in which the coronoid process cannot be visualized there will be bony changes in other areas of the joint that will strongly suggest FCP. If the information from the radiographs is equivocal, a CT scan can typically help significantly in establishing a firm diagnosis. While CT scans are not readily available in all local areas, they are generally available at least regionally, and are a very valuable diagnostic tool for this problem.
The approach to diagnosing ED is consistent, however the approach to treating the problem is variable. Developing a treatment protocol for ED depends not only on the etiology, but also on the symptoms that the dog is demonstrating, as well as the duration of the problem.
Treatment of FCP or OCD can be medical or surgical/medical. I typically recommend that most dogs with FCP or OCD be treated medically at first, and if the results are not satisfactory, surgery should be considered. Medical management would include a moderate exercise restriction as well as a dietary change if warranted. The dietary alteration would be to achieve weight reduction if required and to alter food intake so as to keep growth rate at a relative minimum. The use of chondroprotective agents such as Cosequin, Glycoflex or similar products is appropriate, as well as the use of non steroidal anti-inflammatory medications. If after five to eight weeks, the results of medical management is not satisfactory, surgery can be performed. The surgical technique for both FCP and OCD essentially results in removal of the adversely affected area. Surgery should be followed by the ongoing administration of chondroprotective agents and anti-inflammatory medication if required.
The results of surgical/medical management are generally satisfactory, with some animals experiencing substantial relief but some others showing only moderate improvement. The prognosis for a working dog that has had surgical repair for FCP or OCD being able to work pain and lameness free is fair, and there is a moderate probability of early degenerative joint disease (arthritis).
ED clearly has a genetic basis, however, it is not highly predictable as to which dogs will be affected by its presence. This lack of predictability eliminates our ability to confidently select breeding stock or puppies it they are from a breed that is predisposed to ED. In spite of this low level of predictability, every effort should be made to eliminate this problem. The Orthopedic Foundation for Animals (OFA) does have an elbow registry that will certify elbows at two years of age. They will give preliminary evaluations at any age, and given the surgery available for UAP, screening at five to seven months of age would certainly be prudent. Any dog with radiographic evidence of ED, whether or not they are lame, should probably be eliminated from breeding. It is important to note, however, that dogs with low level changes in an elbow (Grade 1 ED) may never develop any lameness whatsoever. Working these dogs is appropriate as long as the handler is mindful of the possibility of a future lameness. Clearly, if these dogs are being worked, weight should be kept at an appropriate level, and those exercises requiring hard landing on the forelegs should be minimized. Additionally, dogs with very low level changes on a preliminary evaluation should be re-evaluated in six to twelve months. Changes in an elbow that appear significant at a young age may be insignificant at an older age a long as there has been no progression in the changes. These dogs could potentially be clear of ED at a mature age.
Nutrition has also been shown to play a role in the development of ED. The specific factors that have been shown to be of particular consequence are the feeding of high energy foods, especially if fed in excessive volumes, and the level of calcium in the diet.
Rapid growth has been shown to increase the risk of ED. Every effort should be made in those breeds predisposed to ED to keep their growth rate as low as possible by keeping food volumes as well as the energy content low. A higher energy content of a diet increases the likelihood of a dogs consumption surpassing its requirements. Since fat is a substantial component of energy density, fat content of a chosen diet for young dogs should generally be below 17%. Total energy density should be kept below 4.0 kcal/g. This information should be available from the manufacturer of the food.
For many years it was felt that the ratio of calcium to phosphorus in a diet was more important than the absolute volumes. This has been shown to be inaccurate, and current recommendations are that calcium levels should be approximately .9 – 1.5% on a dry matter basis.
In recent years there has been a tremendous surge in nutritional supplements for dogs. Inasmuch as ED is concerned (as well as other skeletal developmental abnormalities) supplementation has the potential to create far more problems than it can prevent. Beware!
Trauma to growing and developing joints can also play a role in ED. Quantitating the effect of trauma is difficult at best, but common sense would suggest that while we want to keep young dogs in good physical condition, we should minimize those activities that would create high impact on developing joints.
Clearly, ED is a complex entity which much has been learned about in recent year, but much more needs to be done if we are to decrease its frequency, as well as its effect on our dogs. Hopefully, the increased awareness of ED on the part of dog owners, as well as continued veterinary research will lead to a significant decreases in the frequency and severity of this nagging problem.
OFA (Orthopedic Foundation for Animals) is looking for a former competitor (any breed, actually) who may have been videoed running an agility course healthy, who subsequently developed ED. They are putting together a film about ED, and the purpose would be to demonstrate the impact of the disease on competition. A dog living near St Louis would be ideal, as they might want to include a snippet on the current condition of the dog.
If your current or former partner fits this and you would like to participate, contact Ann Green on email@example.com.
Dr. Henry De Boer is the Working K-9 Vet. Following his 1973 graduation from Cornell University, he established Pioneer Valley Veterinary Hospital, based in western Massachusetts.
His involvement with working dogs dates to the mid-1960’s when he began training and handling hunting dogs. In 1984 he became involved with the sport of Schutzhund and has gradually risen to the level of national competitor.
Through the years. De Boer has worked both in a training
and veterinary capacity with a wide variety of working dogs. His knowledge and enthusiasm for
working dogs led to the establishment of Working K-9 Veterinary Consultation Services. This
service provides veterinary consultations for working canines and is available by phone, fax,
Picture credits: Orthopedic Foundation for Animals and Gheorghe M. Constantinescu DVM
Comment: Here's a totally anecdotal personal experience. (I'm not a veterinarian.)
When I adopted my BC at five months of age, I had his hips x-rayed without anesthesia. His hips deemed fine at that time.
He became acutely lame in the rear at around two years of age, and I had him x-rayed again under anesthesia. He was mildly dysplastic. I went into a tailspin, because I'd already had some pretty nifty wins with him in Novice obedience and was afraid he'd never be able to jump in the Advanced classes. At that time, I didn't know a single dog who'd had hip surgery that I considered sound enough to jump. That has changed since then, and I know lots of dogs who could do obedience jumping after surgery.
Then I got lucky.
A good friend sent me literature on CHD that (I think) had been put out by the national Labrador club on CHD based on findings by OFA. One thing it said was that many mildly dysplastic dogs experience acute lameness at around two years of age. Even with no treatment at all, many of them adjust to it and show no lameness for many years afterward.
When I told my vet that I was dubious about hip surgery, he said that he'd recommended one hip surgery in 15 years of practice. He said that proper exercise to maintain rear-end muscle tone and joint supplements kept all but the most extreme cases pain-free well past their middle years with no restrictions on their performance activities. (This was before agility came on the scene, co I can't tell you he'd say the same today.)
Jack went on to earn his CDX and run in sheepdog trials until he was nine years old. He's 11 now and still exhibits no lameness in his retirement. He was diagnosed with moderate dysplaysia in both hips at two.
So here's my advice for what it's worth:-
IOW, don't panic. This may not be the end of the world.
My two cents in about running agility
with dogs who have HD and/or bad elbows...
I, on the other hand, x-ray my GSDs from stem to stern every couple of years, and if they ever showed the slightest dysplasia, they're done. I agree muscle mass certainly helps cushion those hips, dogs may never limp or come up lame and live to a ripe old age with HD, but I don't understand WHY anyone would want to continue running a dog despite this?
I imagine it can be very heartbreaking to have competed with a dog and gotten him just where you are happy only to find out they have HD or bad elbows. Unfortunately, that can be life. I just would never want to put my dog at further risk, and I truly believe that's what can happen by continuing. I don't see many dogs competing that have obvious signs of problems, but there are a few, and I gotta say, it's heartbreaking to see them doing their all for their handlers/owners despite their obvious problems.
Agility is a sport that can be physically challenging on
everyone including the dogs. It just boggles my mind that anyone would be proud of the fact
that their dog can still compete with HD or bad elbows - or would even want to! And I'm talking
downright flunking OFA ratings.. Our dogs (or at least mine anyway) and I'm sure most others,
will do anything most times, to please their owners, but would I ask my GSD to compete in
agility knowing she was dysplastic? No, I wouldn't ask it of myself let alone my dog. Just my
plea to two groups of people from Matt Tovey...
Dog-owners: Please check a puppy's parents hip-scores before buying a dog. You can save yourselves and your dog so much pain...
We took our BC Jess to the Munich veterinary clinic where they took another very good quality x-ray and an orthopedic specialist examined her. Despite having stopped agility and having given her medication and supplements, the specialist could see a worsening of Jess's arthritic condition in just one month. He's advised us to stop agility, and we will take his advice.
In preparation for German agility last year, we trained for an obligatory obedience test. As Jess grew confident in her obedience work, she came to enjoy that. So we plan to get her more into obedience.
It's also been very hard to see our little athlete being crippled so, but Jess will get the best life that we can give her. We will continue to do agility with Asterix, although trials are going to be complicated. I hate the idea of taking Jess along, just to watch.
To read Matt & Jess' story, see Euro-Agility.